Eh, you heard the one about the Ang Moh saying Singapore not really Asia because we too rich and clean? Sounds like a joke, but some people really think like that! So, how to deal with these comments when you kena?
Current State of Mindsets
- Many Westerners equate “Asia” with poverty and underdevelopment.
“So asia = poor instead of deifning a geographic region?”
- They struggle to reconcile Singapore’s modernity with their preconceived notions of Asia.
“Translation: it is hard for me to feel superior as a European when a non-European country can do what I can just as well if not better.”
- This often stems from a superiority complex and a need to feel validated.
Singapore’s success challenges their worldview. They cannot accept that a Southeast Asian country can be as, or even more, developed than their own. This leads to comments dismissing Singapore as “not really Asia.” The truth is, geography is geography. Singapore is in Asia, full stop. And we’re proud of it, okay?
The Problematic Assumptions
- Assumptions that wealth and cleanliness are incompatible with Asian identity.
“She’s talking about poverty porn”
- Disrespect towards Singapore’s progress and unique cultural identity.
“They come to this part of the world seeking validation that their part of the world is superior but gets a reality check instead. They come up with excuses like how SG is not really Asia or SEA so that they can accept this anomaly.”
- The underlying arrogance and ignorance behind such statements.
It’s frustrating when people reduce an entire continent to stereotypes. Singapore, with its blend of cultures and rapid development, is a testament to Asia’s diversity and dynamism. These comments reveal more about the speaker’s biases than about Singapore itself. It’s like saying Newton Food Centre isn’t Singaporean because it’s too touristy – doesn’t make sense, right?
How to Respond Like a Pro
- Educate politely but firmly on Singapore’s place in Asia.
“Japan and Korea are just as much Asia as Laos and Cambodia. You can’t cure her myopia”
- Use humour to highlight the absurdity of the statement.
“with how bad DB delays are, maybe Germany is Asia too”
- Focus on the geographical facts.
Next time someone says Singapore isn’t really Asia, try responding with a witty comeback or a simple geographical fact. You could also highlight the irony of their statement, given Singapore’s vibrant Asian culture. Or just tell them to go try queue for chicken rice at Maxwell, then tell you Singapore not Asia! Ultimately, remember that their opinion is just that – an opinion. Don’t let it get to you, and continue to be proud of our little red dot!
