Eh, Hong Kong and Singapore, same same but different or totally not? It’s a question many Singaporeans ponder, especially when planning a quick getaway or just scrolling through travel feeds. Are we truly sister cities, or is that just a surface-level assumption?
Current Perceptions of HK
When Singaporeans talk about Hong Kong, there’s often an initial comparison, a mental checklist of sorts. Are we two peas in a pod, or worlds apart despite our shared status as Asian tiger economies? Online discussions, especially on platforms like Reddit, paint a complex picture, starting with some acknowledged similarities but quickly moving to highlight significant differences.
- Shared City-State Traits
It’s true that on a superficial level, both Singapore and Hong Kong share traits like being densely populated, known for high living costs, and historically serving as major English-speaking financial hubs in Asia. Many businesses and expats move between the two. One Redditor succinctly listed these commonalities.
“city-state ✅ cramped ✅ expensive ✅ English-speaking ✅ majority-Chinese ✅ authoritarian government ✅”
- Growing Divergence and Unique Identities
However, beyond these surface-level points, most Singaporeans feel the two are fundamentally different. Hong Kong’s mountainous terrain contrasts sharply with Singapore’s flat landscape. HK has distinct seasons; we have perpetual summer. They primarily speak Cantonese, we use English as a lingua franca. Moreover, recent political and social shifts in Hong Kong are perceived as widening this gap, making it less of a direct competitor or “sister city” in the eyes of some Singaporeans.
“since the protests/crackdown, COVID and mass emigration, HK has basically been taken over by the mainland and it’s becoming less and less similar to SG every day.”
Realities on The Ground
While Hong Kong’s dynamism is a big draw, some Singaporean visitors have shared challenging on-the-ground experiences. These often concern interactions and the general atmosphere, which can differ from what we’re used to back home.
- Communication and Cultural Interactions
A common point on Reddit is the perceived directness of locals, sometimes seen as rude, especially if you don’t speak Cantonese. This can make simple interactions, like ordering at a busy eatery, feel a bit daunting for Singaporeans accustomed to a different service style. It’s a reminder that cultural norms vary widely, even between seemingly similar cities.
“Run down, crowded and locals can be quite rude esp if you don’t speak Cantonese.”
- Feeling Unwelcome at Times
Some Singaporeans, particularly those trying to communicate in Mandarin, have reported feeling unwelcome or even discriminated against. While not everyone’s experience, these accounts are a sober reminder that navigating cultural sensitivities is key. It can be a stark contrast to the multicultural welcome many expect.
“Felt very discriminated over there… mandarin speaking chinese people get treated badly in Hong Kong so I don’t think much of it?”
A More Balanced Viewpoint
So, what’s the takeaway for Singaporeans thinking about Hong Kong? It’s not about declaring one city superior, but about appreciating their distinct characters and managing expectations for a more rewarding visit.
- Embrace HK’s Unique Offerings
Instead of looking for another Singapore, dive into what makes Hong Kong special. Many Redditors highlight its undeniable vibrancy and “soul,” evident in its bustling streets, diverse food scene beyond just dim sum, and stunning hiking trails. It’s a city with a distinct energy that many find captivating once they tune into its rhythm.
“SG has no soul but HK is super vibrant and is lot more colourful and has depth.”
- Learn and Appreciate Differences
Navigating Hong Kong can also make us appreciate aspects of Singapore more, like our easy multicultural interactions or perceived safety. Understanding these differences enriches travel. Both cities have unique strengths; it’s about finding what resonates with you. One user noted a difference in helpfulness, which can highlight SG’s approachability.
“I would also say Singaporeans in general are more helpful to tourists than HongKongers.”
