Executive Summary

The HardwareZone forum discussions reveal a strong interest in China Mobile CMLink Singapore, particularly for travel to China. Users are exploring various options, including CMLink eSIMs from Hong Kong and comparing them to local Singaporean plans. The debate centers around data allowances, VPN needs, and the overall cost-effectiveness of different solutions. Recent observations include increased data allowances for some users on specific plans and varying experiences with scam calls. CMLink eSIM HK’s 5GB daily plan (approximately SGD 26.50 for 15 days) is highlighted as a value option for heavy data users.

Many users have reported successful access to Google services and other international websites without a VPN when using CMLink eSIMs. However, some still prefer VPNs for specific purposes like accessing streaming services or bypassing potential network restrictions. The conversation also touches upon the challenges of using hotel Wi-Fi in China and the potential for increased data usage. The community is actively sharing tips and recommendations based on their personal experiences, providing valuable insights for prospective users.

Key Developments

eSIM vs. Physical SIM

The discussion clearly indicates a preference for eSIMs, especially for travel. Users like SibehHL are choosing eSIMs for their convenience and ease of use, stating “eSIM saves the trouble of changing physical sim card too.” This eliminates the need to swap physical SIM cards when travelling. This convenience is a key factor for many users.

“Tried out this eSIM plan for the first time. Bought the 15 days unlimited plan (5GB / Day) for approx SGD 27 and so far the experience is good with coverage and speed.” – SibehHL (28 Nov 2024)

CMLink HK eSIM Plan

The CMLink HK eSIM plan offering 5GB daily for approximately SGD 26.50 (converted from CNY 143.50) is a recurring highlight. This is seen as a cost-effective solution for heavy data users when compared to local Singaporean plans or paying for separate VPN services. This plan is often compared to the CMLink Singapore plans. However, some users find the local SIMBA plans more affordable.

“At this moment, I find paying CMLink eSIM HK SGD 26.50 for 5GB daily ( valid 15 days) to be extremely value for $$ when compared to the CMLink SG or CUniq SG plans.” – SibehHL (01 Dec 2024)

Data Allowance Increases

Several users have reported a significant increase in local and roaming data allowances on their existing CMLink Singapore plans. HoGnix notes that certain plans with a 100GB local data promotion now have 200GB local data plus additional data for China, Hong Kong, and ASEAN countries. This change seems to be targeted to specific promotions, not across all CMLink plans.

“For those SGD 10 plan signed on local shop with 100GB per Month promotion. Now with 200GB local data, 3GB China/HK, 3GB Malaysia, Indonesia/Thailand.” – HoGnix (15 Dec 2024)

VPN Usage in China

The need for VPNs is a recurring topic. While some users report being able to access international websites and apps without a VPN when using CMLink eSIM, others still prefer VPNs for streaming or accessing blocked content. User dilphinus reports success using Surfshark in Beijing, while others have had negative experiences with NordVPN. The efficacy of VPNs seems to vary.

“Sharing my experience using Ivacy/PureVPN: Regardless which VPN (paid ones), sometime you will not be able to connect when using hotel/shop Wifi.” – honestguy (29 Nov 2024)

Community Insights

User Experiences

Users like SibehHL have had positive experiences with the CMLink HK eSIM, noting good coverage and download speeds of around 100Mbps. Others confirm successful access to Google services and other international websites without a VPN. However, Mancunian2 notes that some international apps like WhatsApp and Facebook can be unreliable on hotel Wi-Fi, even with a CMLink SIM.

“Tried out this eSIM plan for the first time. Bought the 15 days unlimited plan (5GB / Day) for approx SGD 27 and so far the experience is good with coverage and speed. D/L averages 100Mbps…” – SibehHL (28 Nov 2024)

Some users have reported receiving scam calls on their CMLink numbers, while others have had minimal issues. blurpandasg2014 noted receiving “Full of scam calls daily,” while Milo-Dino reported very few scam calls. This suggests that the prevalence of scam calls may not be solely carrier-dependent. User nakata97 experienced unexpected charges related to iMessage, highlighting a potential issue with iPhones.

“Full of scam calls daily on cmlink number” – blurpandasg2014 (29 Nov 2024)

Tips and Recommendations

Users suggest purchasing CMLink eSIMs directly from CMLink HK for potentially better value. For users concerned about scam calls, HoGnix recommends disabling call forwarding on their CMLink number if the purpose is primarily to receive SMS. Several users recommend exploring proxy options like “simplelink” or “clash” as an alternative to VPNs, especially on ARM processors.

“Suggest to buy directly from CMLink eSIM HK.” – SibehHL (29 Nov 2024)

Users recommend monitoring data usage, especially when streaming. Mancunian2 mentioned that their data was “just about adequate as long as don’t go stream youtube or netflix.” For heavy data users, the CMLink HK 5GB daily plan is often recommended. It’s important to check for any promotional data increases on existing CMLink plans.

Important Considerations

Users should be aware of the potential for scam calls, although experiences vary. It’s crucial to be cautious about sharing your CMLink number. Some users have had issues with iMessage charges, which is an important point for iPhone users. Hotel Wi-Fi in China can be unreliable, potentially impacting the performance of some international apps.

“Turn off iMessage. ZYM also charged me and I was not able to waive. it’s iPhone iMessage problem” – nakata97 (29 Nov 2024)

The data allowances on CMLink plans can vary significantly, so it’s essential to review the details carefully before purchasing. The CMLink HK 5GB daily plan is only valid for 15 days. The cost-effectiveness of different plans depends on individual usage patterns. Users should compare the cost and data allowance of CMLink plans with other options like SIMBA roaming.

Looking Ahead

The community expects to see continued evolution in CMLink plans and data allowances. There is an expectation that CMLink may introduce more competitive roaming data packages to match the increased local data offers. Users are also keenly watching for any changes in VPN effectiveness and are experimenting with different alternatives like proxies.

The community is likely to continue sharing their experiences and tips on using CMLink for travel to China. The debate around VPNs vs. no VPN will likely continue, with users reporting on the performance of various services. Users are also keen to see if the recent data increases will be a permanent feature or a temporary promotion.